Ausschüsse des Verwaltungsrats
Functioning and work of the Board in 2022
The Board met nine times in 2022 (for seven ordinary meetings and two extraordinary meetings) and the average attendance rates were 95% for all meetings and 97% for ordinary meetings. Attendance rates for each director at the Board meetings held in 2022 are shown in paragraph 3.1.3, “Activities in 2022”, page 134.
All documents needed by directors to perform their duties are made available both in hard copy, for those who wish to receive them as such, and in electronic form, the latter via a specific application allowing directors to view the documents on a tablet or computer.
In 2022, all Board meetings were held in person, with some of the directors taking part remotely via videoconferencing.
The Board discussed all matters of importance relating to the Group’s activities. The Executive Vice-President and Chief Financial Officer attends Board meetings. The General Counsel acts as Board Secretary.
Main areas of oversight | Board activities in 2022 |
Review of the financial statements and day-to-day management | • Reviewed and approved the consolidated and parent company financial statements for the year ended 31 December 2021 as well as the consolidated
and parent company financial statements for the six months ended 30 June 2022, reviewed the related press releases, examined the reports of the
Statutory Auditors relating to these financial statements, and reviewed the 2022 budget forecasts and the 2023 budget • Approved the terms of the various reports to shareholders, including the Report of the Board of Directors (which contained the Report on corporate governance), prepared and convened the Shareholders’ General Meeting of 12 April 2022, approved its agenda and the resolutions submitted for shareholder approval • Reviewed the work done by the Audit Committee • Regularly examined the Group’s business activities, ongoing developments, financial situation and indebtedness • Decided on the payment of the dividend in respect of 2021 and the interim dividend in respect of 2022 • Reviewed changes in the share capital and the share buy-back programme • Received information on the arrangement of a new revolving credit facility • Decided to reduce the share capital by cancelling 8.6 million treasury shares • Approved the renewal of the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer’s powers regarding guarantees and collateral as well as the implementation of the share buy-back programme • Renewed the delegation of authority to the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer to record the capital increases carried out by way of the creation of new shares resulting from the exercise of rights and in connection with the Group savings plan and to maintain the rights of beneficiaries of performance shares and shares granted under long-term incentive plans upon leaving the Group • Renewed the delegation of authority to the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer as well as the Executive Vice-President and Chief Financial Officer to issue bonds and was informed of the use of this delegation • Received information in conjunction with the preparation of the interim and annual financial statements identifying financial difficulties experienced by companies in order to prevent insolvency • Reviewed and approved the report on payments to government authorities made by VINCI subsidiaries with respect to their mining and quarrying activities |
Corporate governance | • Reviewed the work done by the Appointments and Corporate Governance Committee • Evaluated the independence of the Board’s members with regard to the criteria of the Afep-Medef code and submitted the appointment of a director for shareholder approval at the Shareholders’ General Meeting • Confirmed the continued application of the system of governance in which the roles of Chairman of the Board and Chief Executive Officer are combined, with Mr Huillard serving in both of these positions • Reappointed Mr Huillard to his positions as Chairman and Chief Executive Officer and Ms Assouad to her position as Lead Director • Changed the composition of the Board committees |
Remuneration | • Reviewed the work done by the Remuneration Committee
• Set Mr Huillard’s variable remuneration for financial year 2021 and established the remuneration policy for the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer in the event of a new term of office • Reviewed and approved the “Company officers’ remuneration and interests” section of the 2021 Universal Registration Document • Decided to set up a performance share plan for the Group’s employees for awards granted under the Twenty-first resolution passed at the Shareholders’ General Meeting of 8 April 2021, as well as a long-term incentive plan for the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer • Approved the vesting percentages under the performance share and long-term incentive plans set up on 17 April 2019 |
Employee savings plans | • Set the subscription price of shares to be issued under the Group savings plan in France for the periods from 1 May to 31 August 2022, from 1
September to 31 December 2022 and from 1 January to 30 April 2023
•Reviewed a proposal for a new international employee share ownership plan for 2023 and granted delegations of authority to set the subscription price as well as the definitive start and end dates for the subscription period in each country concerned •Reaffirmed, subsequent to the Shareholders’ General Meeting, the decisions previously taken by the Board relating to the Castor France and Castor International 2022 company mutual funds •Reviewed the results of the employee share ownership programme offered in 2022 to employees of VINCI’s foreign subsidiaries in connection with the Group savings plan outside France |
Strategy and CSR | • Reviewed the work done by the Strategy and CSR Committee
•Reviewed and approved several acquisition opportunities |
Other | • Responded to questions submitted in writing by shareholders prior to the Shareholders’ General Meeting of 12 April 2022
•Authorised the issue of guarantees •Approved a sponsorship agreement |
All of the Board’s ordinary meetings held in person provided the opportunity for discussions between the directors and the members of the Executive Committee.
A Board meeting in the absence of the executive company officer was held on 3 February 2022, in particular to evaluate his performance and discuss governance.
One of the Board meetings took place in the United Kingdom. In conjunction with this meeting, the Board members received a detailed presentation on the Group’s activities in this country and visited the construction site for the HS2 high-speed rail line.
A Group strategy seminar attended by the directors along with all Executive Committee members was held in Versailles in January 2023.
The Board has established four specialised committees:
➜ The Audit Committee
➜ The Strategy and CSR Committee
➜ The Appointments and Corporate Governance Committee
➜ The Remuneration Committee
The role of the committees is to prepare and provide support for decision-making processes in their respective areas of specialisation. The responsibilities and modus operandi of the committees are governed by the Board’s internal rules. Each committee has consultative powers and acts under the authority of the Board, of which it is an extension and to which it is accountable. Minutes of each committee meeting are drawn up and circulated to the members of the Board.
Each committee may enlist the services of outside consultants to perform technical analyses concerning matters within their remit, at the Company’s expense and after sending notification of this decision to the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer. Each committee is also entitled to invite any experts or other knowledgeable parties to attend its meetings and offer their insights, as necessary.
During the Combined Shareholders’ General Meeting held in April 2022, each of the Board committees presented a report on its activities in 2021.
Prüfungs- ausschuss | Strategie- und Investitions- ausschuss | Vergütungs- ausschuss | Ernennungs- und Governance- ausschuss | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Hr. Xavier Huillard | ||||
Hr. Carlos F. Aguilar | X | |||
Frau Yannick Assouad | X | X | ||
Hr. Benoit Bazin | X | X | ||
Frau Graziella Gavezotti | X | |||
Frau Caroline Grégoire Sainte Marie | X | |||
Hr. Claude Laruelle | X | X | ||
Frau Marie-Christine Lombard | X | X | ||
Hr. René Medori | X | |||
Frau Annette Messemer | X | |||
Hr. Roberto Migliardi | X | |||
Frau Dominique Muller | X | X | ||
Hr. Alain Saïd | X | |||
Hr. Qatar Holding LLC | X |
Prüfungsausschuss
Präsident
Mitglieder
Yannick Assouad, Executive Vice-President, Avionics, Thales, Seniormitglied des Verwaltungsrats
Caroline Grégoire Sainte Marie, Aufsichts- bzw. Verwaltungsratsmitglied in mehreren Unternehmen
Claude Laruelle, Chief Financial Officer, Veolia
Composition
In accordance with the Board’s internal rules, the Audit Committee comprises at least three directors designated by the Board. The Executive Vice-President and Chief Financial Officer and the Statutory Auditors attend Audit Committee meetings. From 17 April 2019 until 12 April 2022, this committee had the following members: Ren. Medori (Chair), Yannick Assouad, Robert Castaigne and Graziella Gavezotti. Since 12 April 2022, its membership has been as follows: Ren. Medori (Chair), Yannick Assouad, Robert Castaigne and Claude Laruelle.
The Board considers all of the Audit Committee members to be independent directors, with the exception of Mr Castaigne.
By virtue of their professional experience and/or qualifications, the members of this committee have the financial, accounting and auditing
expertise necessary to serve thereon, as detailed in the curriculum vitae set out in paragraph 3.2, “Company officers’ appointments and
other positions held”, pages 137 to 140.
The Executive Vice-President and Chief Financial Officer acts as secretary to the Audit Committee.
Responsibilities
The Audit Committee helps the Board monitor the accuracy and fair presentation of VINCI’s parent company and consolidated financial statements, and the quality of the information provided. In particular, its duties are to monitor:
• the process of compiling financial information (i) by examining the Group’s annual and half-year parent company and consolidated financial statements before they are presented to the Board, verifying the quality of the information given to the shareholders; (ii) by ensuring that the accounting policies and methods are appropriate and consistently applied, warning of any deviation from these rules; (iii) by reviewing the scope of consolidation and, where applicable, the reasons why certain companies would not be included; and (iv) by carefully reviewing significant transactions in the course of which a conflict of interest might have arisen, subsequently formulating recommendations to ensure the integrity of such transactions;
• the effectiveness of internal control and risk management systems (i) by verifying the existence of these systems, their proper deployment and the successful implementation of corrective measures in the event of any material weakness or significant deficiency in internal control and (ii) by reviewing the Group’s financial position and major risk factors on a regular basis, examining material risks and off-balance sheet commitments and evaluating the importance of any failures or weaknesses of which it is made aware, bringing them to the attention of the Board where applicable;
• the statutory audit of the parent company and consolidated financial statements and the independence of the Statutory Auditors (i) by tracking the assignments carried out by the Statutory Auditors, including the review of their work programmes, audit conclusions and recommendations, as well as the follow-up actions taken; (ii) by verifying compliance by the Statutory Auditors with their legal obligation to be independent; (iii) by approving the supply of services mentioned in Article L.822-11-2 of the French Commercial Code; and (iv) by evaluating proposals for the appointment of the Company’s Statutory Auditors or the renewal of their terms of office as well as their remuneration and issuing a recommendation on this matter;
• the Group’s policy in respect of insurance;
• the setting up of procedures regarding business ethics and competition, while ensuring that a system is in place able to verify that they
are being enforced;
• the entry into or continuation in force of any agreement concluded between the Company and any of its executive or non-executive
company officers.
To carry out its remit, the Board’s internal rules specify that the Audit Committee may seek external advice, the cost of which is borne by the Company.
Activities in 2022
In its meetings, the main subjects addressed by the Audit Committee were:
• the process of compiling accounting and financial information: review of the Group’s parent company and consolidated financial statements prepared during the year as well as the drafts of the related press releases; presentation of budgets and budget updates; review of the Group’s cash positions and financial debt, its financial strategy and ongoing or completed financial transactions; presentation of the Group’s tax policy and the draft version of the tax transparency report; information on the implementation of the procedure for the assessment of agreements entered into in the ordinary course of business and on an arm’s length basis;
• the effectiveness of the Group’s internal control and risk management systems: analysis of the results of the annual 2022 self-assessment; presentation of the system in use at VINCI Immobilier and VINCI Construction UK; presentation of the annual internal control reports for 2021 issued by the business lines and divisions; update on the situation at a foreign subsidiary; post-mortem review of difficult contracts; presentation of the “Risk factors and management procedures” chapter of the Report of the Board of Directors; review of ongoing disputes and litigation; update of the Group’s risk mapping exercise, including both social and environmental risks; presentation of the 2022 audit programme and its updates; review of off-balance sheet commitments at 31 December 2021 and 30 June 2022; presentation by the Group Purchasing Coordination Director on energy purchases in France;
• the statutory auditing of the parent company and consolidated financial statements and the independence of the Statutory Auditors: discussions with the Statutory Auditors and review of their conclusions, adherence to legal and regulatory obligations concerning accounting and financial information, presentation of the external audit approach;
• insurance: presentation of the Group’s insurance programme and the project to set up a captive reinsurance subsidiary, VINCI Re.
For the purposes of this work, the following executives were interviewed: the Executive Vice-President and Chief Financial Officer; the Director of Cash Management, Financing and Tax Matters; the Senior Vice-President for Corporate Controlling and Accounting; the Chief Audit Officer; the General Counsel; the Group Purchasing Coordination Director; the Energy Procurement Manager; and the Statutory Auditors. During their presentation, the Statutory Auditors emphasised the important points relating to their assignment and the accounting options chosen.
Strategie- und CSR-Ausschuss
Präsident
Benoit Bazin, Chief Operating Officer of Saint-Gobain
Mitglieder
Carlos F. Aguilar, President and CEO, Old Hundred Road, LLC
Annette Messemer, Aufsichts- bzw. Verwaltungsratsmitglied in mehreren Unternehmen
Dominique Muller, Mitglied des Aufsichtsrats des Mitarbeiterbeteiligungsfonds FCPE Castor, Leiterin der Versicherungsabteilung, VINCI Construction France
Alain Saïd, Business Manager, Comsip
Director representing employees
Qatar Holding LLC, Permanent representative: Abdullah Hamad Al Attiyah
Composition
n accordance with the Board’s internal rules, the Strategy and CSR Committee comprises at least three directors designated by the Board. From 18 June 2020 until 12 April 2022, this committee had seven directors as permanent members: Yves-Thibault de Silguy (Chair), Uwe Chlebos, Caroline Grégoire Sainte Marie, Dominique Muller, Ana Paula Pessoa, Pascale Sourisse and the permanent representative of Qatar Holding LLC. Since 12 April 2022, its membership has been as follows: Benoit Bazin (Chair), Caroline Grégoire Sainte Marie, Dominique Muller, Ana Paula Pessoa, Alain Saïd, Pascale Sourisse and the permanent representative of Qatar Holding LLC.
Abdullah Hamad Al Attiyah has been the permanent representative of Qatar Holding LLC since 6 December 2018.
All Board members who wish to do so may attend the Strategy and CSR Committee’s meetings, with voting rights. Before each meeting, a dossier on the items to be discussed is sent to all directors.
VINCI’s Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, Executive Vice-President and Chief Financial Officer, and Vice-President for Business Development attend the meetings of the Strategy and CSR Committee. The Board Secretary acts as secretary to this committee.
Responsibilities
The Strategy and CSR Committee helps the Board review the Group’s overall strategy. In advance of their presentation to the Board, it examines multi-year contracts implying an investment on the part of the Group, strategic investments and all transactions, including acquisitions and disposals, with the potential to have a material impact on the Group’s scope of consolidation, business activities, risk profile, earnings or balance sheet or on the Company’s stock market valuation. It also monitors all corporate social responsibility issues.
In particular its duties are to:
• prepare the Board’s discussions on the Group’s strategy;
• express an opinion, for the benefit of the Executive Management, on proposed acquisitions or disposals of shareholdings of a value exceeding €50 million that do not come under the Board’s direct terms of reference;
• give its opinion to the Executive Management on plans for significant changes to the Group’s legal or operational structure
ensure that matters relating to corporate social responsibility are taken into account in the Group’s strategy and its implementation;
• ensure that whistleblowing systems have been put in place within the Group and are functioning well;
• review the report required under Article L.225-102-1 of the French Commercial Code in relation to corporate social responsibility;
• examine the VINCI Group’s sustainability commitments with respect to the issues faced in its business activities and in achieving its objectives.
In addition, this committee is kept informed by the Executive Management of progress made on proposed multi-year contracts involving a total investment by the VINCI Group in equity and debt of more than €100 million.
Activities in 2022
In its meetings, the Strategy and CSR Committee addressed the following subjects in particular:
• six acquisition projects in Energy and Construction;
• eight acquisition opportunities in Concessions, notably for airport concessions;
• update on the implementation of civic engagement initiatives;
• update on the implementation of ethics and vigilance actions;
• progress report on the Group’s environmental ambition.
Vergütungsausschuss
Präsident
Marie-Christine Lombard, Vorstandsvorsitzende von Geodis
Mitglieder
Graziella Gavezotti, Director, Edenred SA
René Medori, Non-executive Chairman, Petrofac Ltd
Roberto Migliardi, Business Engineer, Axians Communication & Systems
Director representing employees
Composition
In accordance with the Board’s internal rules, the Remuneration Committee comprises at least three directors designated by the Board. From 8 April 2021 until 12 April 2022, this committee had the following members: Marie-Christine Lombard (Chair), Benoit Bazin, Miloud Hakimi and Pascale Sourisse. Since 12 April 2022, its membership has been as follows: Marie-Christine Lombard (Chair), Graziella Gavezotti, Roberto Migliardi and Pascale Sourisse.
With the exception of Mr Migliardi, one of the two Directors representing employees, and of Ms Sourisse, all of this committee’s members are considered independent by the Board.
The Vice-President responsible for Human Resources attends the meetings of this committee. The Chairman and Chief Executive Officer also attends these meetings except when the committee examines questions relating personally to him. The Board Secretary acts as secretary to this committee.
Responsibilities
• submit a draft of resolutions to the Board intended to be put to a non-binding vote at the annual Shareholders’ General Meeting relating to the remuneration of executive company officers;
• propose to the Board the setting up of long-term incentive plans for executives and employees, involving grants of performance share awards or of subscription or purchase options on the Company’s shares, as well as the general and specific terms and conditions applying to these grants;
• express an opinion on the Executive Management’s proposals regarding the number of beneficiaries;
• propose to the Board an aggregate amount of remuneration payable to its members and the manner of its allocation.
In addition, the Remuneration Committee is informed of the remuneration policy applicable to the main senior executives who are not company officers.
Activities in 2022
In its meetings, the Remuneration Committee addressed the following subjects in particular:
• assessment of the performance of VINCI’s Executive Management, carried out jointly with the Appointments and Corporate Governance Committee;
• joint determination with the Appointments and Corporate Governance Committee of the criteria applicable for the evaluation of the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer’s managerial performance in 2021;
• determination of the variable component of Mr Huillard’s remuneration for financial year 2021;
• determination of the remuneration policy applicable to Mr Huillard for a new term of office;
• noting of the fulfilment of performance conditions for the long-term incentive and performance share plans set up on 17 April 2019 and determination of the proportion of the awards able to vest;
• validation of the “Company officers’ remuneration and interests” section of the Universal Registration Document;
• examination of draft resolutions relating to the remuneration policy for company officers and the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer in respect of 2022 and the remuneration paid in 2021 to company officers and the executive company officer;
• examination of draft ordinary resolutions to be submitted for shareholder approval at the 2022 Shareholders’ General Meeting relating to the Group savings plan;
• review of a proposal for a qualified performance share plan to be put in place in 2022 for employees and senior executives other than the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer;
• review of a proposal for a long-term incentive plan to be put in place in 2022 for the executive company officer;
• determination of the performance conditions applicable to the performance share and long-term incentive plans to be put in place beginning in 2022;
• update on the employee share ownership policy in France and around the world.
Ernennungs- und Governance-Ausschuss
Präsident
Yannick Assouad, Executive Vice-President, Avionics, Thales, Seniormitglied des Verwaltungsrats
Mitglieder
Benoit Bazin, Chief Operating Officer of Saint-Gobain
Claude Laruelle, Chief Financial Officer, Veolia
Marie-Christine Lombard, Vorstandsvorsitzende von Geodis
Dominique Muller, Mitglied des Aufsichtsrats des Mitarbeiterbeteiligungsfonds FCPE Castor, Leiterin der Versicherungsabteilung, VINCI Construction France
Composition
In accordance with the Board’s internal rules, the Appointments and Corporate Governance Committee comprises at least three directors designated by the Board. From 18 June 2020 until 12 April 2022, this committee had the following members: Yannick Assouad (Chair), Benoit Bazin, Robert Castaigne, Marie-Christine Lombard and Yves-Thibault de Silguy. Since 12 April 2022, its membership has been as follows: Yannick Assouad (Chair), Benoit Bazin, Robert Castaigne, Claude Laruelle and Marie-Christine Lombard.
The Board recognises four of these five members as independent.
The Chairman and Chief Executive Officer attends this committee’s meetings except when it performs its assessment of the Executive Management. The Board Secretary acts as secretary to this committee.
Responsibilities
With respect to appointments, the Appointments and Corporate Governance Committee:
• examines all candidacies for appointments to the Board and expresses an opinion and/or recommendation to the Board on those candidacies;
• prepares, in a timely manner, recommendations and opinions on the appointment of executive company officers and succession plans;
• examines, on a consultative basis, the Executive Management’s proposals relating to the appointment and dismissal of the Group’s main senior executives;
• is informed of the Executive Management’s policy for managing the Group’s senior executives and, in this regard, examines the procedures for succession plans;
• expresses an opinion on the membership of committees and makes proposals for the appointment and renewal of the Chair of the Audit Committee.
With respect to corporate governance, the Appointments and Corporate Governance Committee:
• verifies adherence to the rules of corporate governance and ensures that the recommendations of the Afep-Medef code are being followed, while also making sure that any departures from this code are justified, particularly in the chapter of the Universal Registration Document dedicated to corporate governance;
• supervises the process for the assessment of the work of the Board;
• prepares the Board’s discussions on the assessment of the Company’s Executive Management in consultation with the Remuneration Committee;
• reviews the independence of serving Board members each year.
Activities in 2022
Among the items of business handled in its meetings, the Appointments and Corporate Governance Committee:
• performed the assessment of VINCI’s Executive Management with regard to the managerial criteria adopted for 2021;
• carried out this assessment of VINCI’s Executive Management together with the Remuneration Committee;
• jointly determined with the Remuneration Committee the criteria applicable for the evaluation of the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer’s managerial performance in 2022;
• evaluated each Board member with regard to the independence criteria of the Afep-Medef code and made proposals to the Board;
• reviewed chapter C of the Report of the Board of Directors, “Report on corporate governance”, included in the 2021 Universal Registration Document;
• reviewed the decision on the separation of the roles of Chairman and Chief Executive Officer as well as the functioning of the Board;
• reviewed Board members whose terms of office will end in 2023;
• approved the decision to have an independent recruitment firm assist with the selection of several candidates for the position of director and discussed the status of this process;
• noted the designation of two Directors representing employees whose terms of office commenced after the Shareholders’ General Meeting of 12 April 2022;
• examined the governance system to be put in place following the 2022 Shareholders’ General Meeting;
• received a presentation on succession plans for Executive Committee members and on the succession plan for the executive company officer;
• launched the process for the assessment of the work of the Board with the assistance of an independent firm and reviewed the report on the process drawn up by this firm.